Album review

The Replacements

The Replacements

The Replacements, as is the way with acts whose fanbase acquires the devotion and pettiness of a cult, have always borne a myth that they were at their best earliest. They weren’t, but these reissues of their first four releases ('Sorry Ma, Forgot To Take Out The Trash', 'Stink', 'Hootenanny', 'Let It Be'), nonetheless represent an incalculably influential canon.

1984’s magnificent “Let It Be” in particular is the Rosetta Stone of modern American indie, a ragged assemblage of unreconstructed punk (“Gary’s Got A Boner”), anti-corporate rage (“Seen Your Video”), achingly pretty angst (“Unsatisfied”) and the now-obligatory desecration of a mainstream rock staple (Kiss’s “Black Diamond”).

Worth buying again for the bonus material, including rehearsal-room-rattling readings of T-Rex’s “20th Century Boy” and The Grass Roots’ “Temptation Eyes”, and a demo of “Answering Machine” – the latter an unimprovable study in the furious, impotent rage of someone blaming the medium for the message.

ANDREW MUELLER

Pic credit: Redferns

Rating: 5 / 10

(Rhino)


Newsletter


Editor's Letter

The Father, The Sun And The Holy Ghost… An interview with Hiss Golden Messenger


One bright Sunday morning, MC Taylor is driving through his patch of North Carolina, past New Hope Creek and the Eno River, over the Chatham County Line and the James Taylor Bridge in Chapel Hill, near the Haw River and the valley that he has meditated upon in song these past few years. Through...